The Debate Over Data Ownership: Should You Have More Control Over Your Digital Footprint?

Photo of author

By Aashik Ibrahim

Data ownership has gained importance in the current digital era, where every click, search, and interaction generates data. The legal rights and authority that people or organizations have over data that is created, gathered, and kept are referred to as data ownership.”

data ownership

In Image: Illustration of Data Security


The argument over data ownership is becoming increasingly heated as technology becomes more integrated into our daily lives. This raises important issues about permission, privacy, and the appropriate use of personal data. The complexity of data ownership is examined in this article, along with its effects on people, companies, and society at large. A more egalitarian framework that gives people more control over their digital imprint is also advocated for.

Data Ownership

Image: An illustration of a person using his laptop


The History of Information Gathering

In the past, gathering data was a laborious procedure with limited scope and size. Through purchases, questionnaires, and surveys, businesses obtained direct consumer information. But with the development of the internet and the widespread use of digital devices, data collection became a ubiquitous, automated process. Every online action that people do these days, from using mobile applications to viewing websites, creates enormous volumes of data. The issue of data ownership is becoming more and more heated since this data is often gathered inadvertently and without the user’s express permission.

Big Data’s Ascent

As businesses came to understand the enormous value of the data being gathered, the phrase “big data” was born. Businesses might use machine learning and sophisticated analytics to mine this data for insights that would help them target advertising, enhance goods, and streamline operations. However, concerns about data ownership and privacy started to surface when businesses like Google, Facebook, and Amazon began to collect vast amounts of personal data. People were outraged and demanded more control and transparency over personal data when they saw that businesses were making money off of information that they had unintentionally given to them.

Data Ownership

Image: Bunch of people working in an office


Data as Property: The Court Case Discussion

Whether or not data should be recognized as property is one of the main issues in the discussion around data ownership. People would have ownership rights over data that are comparable to those they have over tangible goods if data were regarded as property. This would entail having the ability to decide who may access their data, sell it or lease it, and demand payment for using it. Nevertheless, data is intangible and may be replicated without loss, which is one reason why the legal system has found it difficult to define it in this manner.

Existing Legal Structures

At the moment, different national and regional laws and regulations regulate data ownership differently. The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) of the European Union gives people important rights over their data, including the ability to view, correct, and delete their personal data. In accordance with the GDPR, businesses must also seek express permission from people before collecting personal data and notify them of the intended use of their data. Conversely, the United States does not have a comprehensive federal law protecting data, and state laws and sector-specific rules mostly control data ownership.

Making the Case for More Power to Own Data

Stronger data ownership rights proponents contend that people need to have greater authority over the personal data they possess. This covers the rights to request the deletion of personal data, to know what data is being collected, and to be able to opt out of data collection. More rights to own data would enable people to take charge of their digital footprint and stop businesses from using their information for commercial purposes without permission. Additionally, it would motivate businesses to create more moral strategies for the gathering and use of data, as well as to be more open and honest about their data practices.

Data Ownership

Image: Illustration of the Legal Obligation of Data Ownership


The Unbalanced Power Between Individuals and Companies

An important ethical consideration in relation to data ownership is the disparity in power between people and corporations. While people often lack the information and resources to preserve their privacy, large digital corporations have the means and know-how to gather, examine, and profit from enormous quantities of data. Due to this disparity in power, businesses may engage in exploitative activities, which include gathering and using customer data against their best interests. For instance, behavior may be manipulated, and negative preconceptions may be reinforced by targeted advertising that uses personal data.

The Dangers of Abuse of Data

The likelihood of data abuse is also intimately related to data ownership. Companies may utilize personal information in ways that are detrimental to people or society when they have unfettered access to it. Data breaches, for instance, may reveal private information that might result in identity theft and financial damage. Furthermore, businesses may use data to discriminate against people by, for example, refusing them access to services or raising their pricing in response to personal data. These dangers emphasize the need for more responsibility from businesses that gather and utilize data, as well as stronger rights to data ownership.

Consent’s Function in Data Ownership

One essential component of data ownership is consent. The choice of whether and how personal data is gathered should belong to the individual. In actuality, however, getting real permission may be difficult. Many individuals are unaware of the full ramifications of data collection and the uses to which their data may be put. Furthermore, permission forms are often lengthy and intricate, which makes it challenging for people to make wise choices. Individuals must have more control over their data via easier, more transparent permission procedures in order to overcome these obstacles.

The Importance of Data to Enterprises

Data is an important resource for organizations because it can spur creativity, increase productivity, and improve client experiences. Businesses utilize data to create new business models, improve supply networks, and customize goods and services. Because of this, companies often find it difficult to relinquish control over the data they gather. Nonetheless, businesses are coming under more and more pressure to implement more ethical and transparent data practices as the discussion over data ownership heats up.

Juggling Privacy and Profit

A major problem facing companies is striking a balance between privacy and profit. Data is vital for competitiveness and development, but businesses also need to respect people’s rights to privacy and ownership of their data. As a result, companies must implement ethical data practices, such getting express permission, collecting as little data as possible, and safeguarding it against breaches. Companies should also think about how their use of data affects people and society and take action to lessen any negative consequences.

Data Governance’s Function

The structure that businesses employ to oversee data ownership, security, and privacy is known as data governance. In order to ensure compliance with legal and regulatory requirements, clear rules and processes for data collection, storage, and usage must be established. This is what is known as effective data governance. Enterprises that use robust data governance protocols are more adept at safeguarding the data ownership rights of people and fostering consumer trust. Effective data governance may also shield businesses against expensive data breaches and fines from the law.

Decentralized Data Ownership Models’ Ascent

New forms of data ownership are developing in response to the ongoing discussion about data ownership, with the goal of giving people more control over their data. Decentralized data ownership is one such concept that makes use of blockchain technology to give people ownership and control over their data. People may keep their data on a blockchain in a decentralized format and offer access to it as needed. People now have more control over their data and may profit from its usage, either selling it to businesses or utilizing it to access services.

Artificial Intelligence’s Function in Data Ownership

The argument over data ownership is also becoming more and more influenced by artificial intelligence (AI). Since AI algorithms need vast volumes of data to operate, questions of data ownership and privacy are raised. Clear rules on data collection, usage, and ownership are required as AI becomes more widely employed. This entails making certain that people are in charge of their data and that AI systems are created with ethical and privacy concerns in mind.

Global Data Ownership Standards Are Necessary

Global regulations on data ownership are becoming more and more necessary as data moves across boundaries. At the moment, disparate national and local rules regulate data ownership, which causes gaps in protection and inconsistencies. Global standards would provide a uniform framework for data ownership, guaranteeing the protection of people’s rights wherever their data is gathered or kept. Global standards would also make it easier for nations to collaborate on data security and privacy, which would aid in addressing the problems associated with data ownership in an increasingly interconnected world.

Data ownership is a complicated topic with many facets that involve ethical, legal, and commercial issues. The issue of who owns our data is becoming more urgent as our lives become more digital. There is a growing understanding that people need to have greater control over their digital footprint, even though the legal structures in place now provide some safeguards.

“This involves innovative forms of data ownership that empower people, more transparent data processes, and greater rights to data ownership. Businesses must strike a balance between the need for data-driven innovation and their rights to privacy and data ownership. In light of the ongoing discourse around data ownership, it is imperative that we establish a fairer structure that safeguards people’s entitlements and encourages moral data use within our virtual community.”

Leave a Comment